2012 ACM Awards Preview & Predictions

March 29, 2012 - By Trigger  //  Random Notes  //  17 Comments

Well shit, it looks like the Academy of Country Music Awards are this Sunday, so what better to get you prepared than to hold this charade up to the light and see what we’ve got. You should expect Reba McEntire’s skin to be taut, Blake Shelton’s jokes to be flat, Taylor Swift reactions to be be precocious, and let’s all pray to Jesus that the camera doesn’t find Keith Urban’s wife, the refined and elegant Nicole Kidman, whose been molding her physical appearance for years now to become a replica of Skeletor for the upcoming He-Man remake.

You can’t mention the ACM’s without framing them in the context of being the bastard son to the much more important and fair CMA’s. Folks love to smirk that all these award shows are rigged, well the ACM’s are the ones we know for sure are dominated by Music Row politics and the practice of block voting, where labels trade votes to get specific artists they want to push nominated and awarded. Last year this practice came to light when it was revealed Miranda Lambert was favored over Carrie Underwood.

Either way, you can argue it is country music’s 2nd most important night, whether you like shaking your fist at the country music industry or not, so SCM will be there to cover it. You’re invited to turn your TV on and your snark machine up and join us for the SCM Live Blog on the ACM’s Sunday night. In the meantime, let’s look at what we have in regards to candidates and awards.

Entertainer of the Year

  • Jason Aldean
  • Kenny Chesney
  • Brad Paisley
  • Blake Shelton
  • Taylor Swift – Win

This is a two horse race between Taylor Swift and Jason Aldean. Man vs. woman, real vs. fake, pop vs. more pop. In the end I expect Taylor Swift to run away with the award because the Entertainer of the Year is fan voted. Legions of glitter faced little girls will outlast Aldean’s winshield cowboy fanbase that is boggled by any technology beyond their Bluetooth.

Male Vocalist of the Year

  • Jason Aldean – Win
  • Kenny Chesney
  • Brad Paisley
  • Blake Shelton
  • Chris Young

This is Jason Aldean’s to lose, and it becomes more likely for him if the fans vote Taylor Swift for Entertainer of the Year. The other contender could be Blake Shelton, bolstered by the popularity of “The Voice” TV show. Chris Young is the sleeper with an outside chance. He’s been getting a lot of industry buzz lately, and being on the major Music Row label of RCA compared to Aldean’s independent Broken Bow gives him a very slight chance of tipping the scales. It’s also worth noting that Brad Paisley has won this award for the last 5 years.

Female Vocalist of the Year

  • Sara Evans
  • Miranda Lambert – Win
  • Martina McBride
  • Taylor Swift
  • Carrie Underwood

Miranda Lambert deserves it. Slight chance Taylor Swift might steal it, but the way the timeline lines up, this is an off year for Taylor and the ACM’s since her last album came out over a year ago. Miranda has released two solid albums recently, a solo one and one with The Pistol Annies, and her label has already proved they will go to bat for her behind-the-scenes. Unless some unforeseen label politics get in the way, Miranda walks with the hardware.

Vocal Group of the Year

  • The Band Perry – Win
  • Eli Young Band
  • Lady Antebellum
  • Rascal Flatts
  • Zac Brown Band

Let’s just call a spade a spade, and rename this category “Best Hair”. In the end, I expect Nashville’s new favorite toy in The Band Perry and the Perry brothers’ Frodo Baggins mop tops to mop the floor with Rascal Flatts’ bleached and over-moosed doos. Though Rascal Flatts’ hair is as overproduced and extra-perfect as their music, it is beginning to fall out-of-style. Give Lady Antebellum and outside chance in this beauty contest, stunted slightly by Hillary Scott’s newfound post-marriage heft.

Vocal Duo of the Year

  • Love and Theft
  • Montgomery Gentry
  • Steel Magnolia
  • Sugarland
  • Thompson Square – I Guess

Oh gosh, what a paltry collection of odds and sods this is, illustrating the ridiculousness of the modern-day country duo. The spirit of this award was to highlight country music’s legendary pairings of the past, like George & Tammy, and Willie & Waylon. Brooks & Dunn was the only thing keeping this category relevant for the last few years. Then when Music Row figured out they could create these duos to gain free exposure through award shows, the concept got out of hand. I guess give me Thompson Square for the win, with Sugarland having an outside chance from the strength of their 2011 touring. Where are The Civil Wars?

New Artist of the Year

  • Brantley Gilbert – Win
  • Hunter Hayes
  • Scotty McCreery

The two fresh-faced boys will fall to the “Official Country Music Douche” Brantley Gilbert, unbeknownst to his fan base that will be too busy waxing their scrotums, or cooking up the latest batch of methamphetamine in their bathtubs.

Album of the Year

  • Chief – Eric Church (EMI-Nashville)
  • Four The Record – Miranda Lambert (RCA)
  • Hemingway’s Whiskey – Kenny Chesney (BNA)
  • My Kinda Party – Jason Aldean (Broken Bow Records)Win
  • Own The Night – Lady Antebellum (Capitol Records Nashville)

My Kinda Party is the sure bet, but Four The Record, Hemingway’s Whiskey, and Own The Night could all sneak up and win if their labels are really looking to push them. Eric Church’s Chief probably does not have a chance, but it is an achievement for Church to even be nominated. It is easy to think of Eric Church as just making it out of the club circuit because his climb has been slow and not marked by the big bursts that usually usher in super stardom, but bolstered by a rabid fan base, he’s selling out arenas, and is becoming a bona-fide country music franchise.

Single of the Year

  • Crazy Girl – Eli Young Band (Republic Nashville)
    Produced by: Mike Wrucke
  • Don’t You Wanna Stay – Jason Aldean With Kelly Clarkson (Broken Bow Records)
    Produced by: Michael Knox
  • Red Solo Cup – Toby Keith (Show Dog-Universal Music)
    Produced by: Toby Keith
  • Tomorrow – Chris Young (RCA)
    Produced by: James Stroud
  • You And Tequila – Kenny Chesney Featuring Grace Potter (BNA)
    Produced by: Buddy Cannon, Kenny Chesney

Wow, this list is a joke, and the moment where Music Row politics got in the way of putting together any real sensical list of nominees. Toby Keith’s “Red Solo Cup” makes a mockery of the whole category, the whole ACM process, and the awards themselves, but a little part of me hopes it wins anyway just to expose the ridiculousness of the whole thing. I guess “You And Tequila” is the most likely win, but in reality the winner will be whatever song the suits huddled around a table decide needs to be “pushed” the most.

Song of the Year

  • Crazy Girl – Eli Young Band
    Composers: Lee Brice, Liz Rose
  • Home – Dierks Bentley
    Composers: Brett Beavers, Dierks Bentley, Dan Wilson
  • Just A Kiss – Lady Antebellum
    Composers: Dallas Davidson, Dave Haywood, Charles Kelley, Hillary Scott
  • Threaten Me With Heaven – Vince Gill
    Composers: Amy Grant, Vince Gill, Dillon O’Brian, Will Owsley
  • You And Tequila – Kenny Chesney Featuring Grace Potter
    Composers: Matraca Berg, Deana Carter

A little bit better list than the singles, but not by much. Again, I hope the process fails the country music consumer and exposes its ridiculousness by electing Dierks Bentley’s “Home” whose authenticity as an original song has been questioned by performer (and possible future songwriter credit) Jason Isbell. Vince Gill should win, but won’t. Songs are what all of music breaks down to, and what is charged with touching your heart. The country music consumer should be embarrassed and angered by these song lists, and expect more from the ACM’s.

17 Comments to “2012 ACM Awards Preview & Predictions”

  • I think you’re spot on with these. I can’t wait to watch this and read your comments throughout the donkey show. Wait I mean ACMs…


  • Well real artists like Hank 3 and Marty Stuart are collaborating on good songs like Picture from Lifes Other Side. There’s a good article.


    • I’ve wanted to write a story about that for 6 weeks. Unfortunately all the info I have for it you just conveyed in that one sentence. If folks would email me back, maybe I could/will post something about it.

      But I know what you’re saying.


  • ” Legions of glitter faced little girls will outlast Aldean’s winshield cowboy fanbase that is boggled by any technology beyond their Bluetooth” funniest thing I’ve read all day!


  • i think you pretty much got it all Trig. And Miranda’s two albums this year were solid plays.


  • Wait a second. There’s gonna be a He-Man remake?!


    • I hear Dan Dierdorf is going to play “Man At Arms”


      • on.


  • no interest so i won’t be watching.


    • Me neither John. I was rooting around for country music and found none so I’ll crank up my ipod, sit on my front porch with an adult beverage or maybe just listen to the crickets and frogs, a much more pleasing sound.


  • The last time I watched this televised abortion was when my man Dwight Yoakam was on it. It just gets worse every year. The terrible thing about Kenny Chesney is you can tell he knows his music sucks, and in a couple interviews the music he says he actually listens to isn’t bad. He’s openly doing it for the money, which in a way isn’t as bad as pretending to be legit. He’s just getting wasted on a boat somewhere while the braindead frat boy public laps up the plastic garbage beach songs a couple of corporate-hired nerds back in Nashville composed for him.


  • I’m sure you meant Reba’s skin will be taut, else I’ll forever wonder what it has learned :)


    • Good catch. I won’t even blame the spell checker for that one.


  • Is it unusual that the person most likely to win EOTY isn’t even performing? I wouldn’t know since I forget these things as soon as they’re through. Not to say it indicates she is any less likely to win; it just comes across as odd.

    It’s been Jason’s year, as far as I can tell, so it seems sort of unfair that he would lose, but that’s probably the way it’s going to go. That award should really go to Taylor’s cat Meredith who is more entertaining than all these people.


    • I personally think BMR will let Taylor lost on every categories she’s been nominated, to avoid over-exposure.

      I’m cool if Taylor lost to Brad Paisley or Kenny Chesney. Brad is a neo-traditionalist and a great guitar player, while Kenny has the number.

      But Aldean or Shelton? Nope. In a million years.

      By the way, do you have an account in ATRL too?


  • What!!! No Moonshine Bandits????
    On a serious note ; Poop.


  • I woke up, finally, this morning, April 2, 2012, checked the paper and the web but, alas the ACM award show last night was NOT an April fool’s day joke! How tragic! Where was the REAL country? The closest was Reba and she didn’t even sing and they did have Toby sing his gimmick song then anod to Earl Scruggs. Sure there was some talent there, but country, well IMHO, not so much. HOW could it be real country without even a mention, and of course a nomination for (partial list): Dolly, Emmy Lou, Allison Kraus, Hank, Jr., George Strait, Trace Adkins, Alan Jackson, etc, etc .


Leave a comment

Del Maguey
Old Soul Radio Show
Modern Roots
Best Of Lists