25 Artists More Deserving of Opry Invitation Than Darius Rucker

On Tuesday night (10-2-12) Brad Paisley popped out of the crowd at the Grand Ole Opry and surprised everyone by presenting former Hootie & The Blowfish frontman turned pop country star Darius Rucker with an invitation to become the Grand Ole Opry’s newest member. The invitation came a week after Gaylord Entertainment’s $210 million sale to Marriott International was approved by shareholders.

As a frame of reference, you can cull through the vast Saving Country Music archives, and aside from maybe a passing comment, you will find no ill will towards Hootie around here, no negative reviews or features of any sort. No matter what you think of the man, he’s generally kept his nose clean over the years, understanding that he is privileged to be amongst the mainstream country ranks, and no, not because of his race.

The problem with this invitation is that he is a country interloper, a carpetbagger who came to the genre like so many others to save a dying pop rock career. And we don’t even know how long he will stay. He said in late July that Hootie & The Blowfish are reuniting and recording new music. But here we are, handing Hootie country’s most coveted invitation with a lifetime guarantee when there’s so many other artists out there so much more deserving.

And the invitation is so obvious. It’s a headline maker. How about showing the man some respect by letting him earn the invitation, as opposed to using him as a prop for a publicity blitz? It is good that the Opry finally has another black member, but not that it is being done this way.

SCM’s Top 25 Artists Deserving Opry Membership

  1. Hank Williams
  2. Willie Nelson
  3. Merle Haggard
  4. Dwight Yoakam
  5. George Strait
  6. Miranda Lambert
  7. Jamey Johnson
  8. Lee Ann Womack
  9. Hank Williams Jr.
  10. Zac Brown
  11. Kellie Pickler
  12. Rosanne Cash
  13. Ronnie Dunn
  14. Dale Watson
  15. Mark Chesnutt
  16. Jo Dee Messina
  17. Sam Bush
  18. Elizabeth Cook
  19. Easton Corbin
  20. Jack Ingram
  21. Gene Watson
  22. Josh Abbot
  23. “Cousin” Kenny Vaughan
  24. Eli Young
  25. Aaron Tippin


And after sleeping on this list, 6 other names that probably deserve to be on it somewhere:

  • Billy Joe Shaver
  • Kris Kristofferson
  • Robert Earl Keen
  • Asleep At The Wheel
  • Gary Stewart
  • And though nowhere near the top for sure, but still probably more deserving than Darius – Taylor Swift

And just in case you were wondering where Hootie would be on my list? Well, you have to fast-forward pretty far…

722. Goo Goo Dolls

723. 80’s one hit wonder band “Mister Mister”

724. Limahl – The guy that sang the theme song to The NeverEnding Story. This dude:

725. Darius Rucker

726. Billy Ray Cyrus’s mullet

727. Garth Brooks’ enlarged prostate

728. Kid Rock

I tried to be practical when making my list, but if all things were equal (and taking into consideration the Opry’s family friendly environment), here are some names from the underground/independent country world that would deserve an Opry nod:

  • Wayne “The Train” Hancock
  • James Hand
  • Caleb Klauder
  • Rachel Brooke
  • Lucky Tubb
  • Caitlin Rose
  • Justin Townes Earle
  • Whitey Morgan
  • JB Beverley
  • Chris Scruggs

Who would you like to see in the Grand Ole Opry?