Album Review – Whitney Rose’s “We Still Go To Rodeos”

Hats off and all due respect to other styles of music, but when you want to hear something that sounds like the breaking of the human heart, nothing holds up to country. A honky tonk sweetheart and certified heartbreaker originally from Canada, Whitney Rose knows this maxim all to well, and has built a career upon it, once declaring that if she can’t wear her boots, she ain’t going.
But for the second record in a row, Whitney Rose has eased off her original traditional country sound that pegged the honky tonk meter at “10” to add a little more old school rock ‘n roll flavor and fervor to her music. It’s not necessarily at the expense of twang or writing songs with a storytelling approach as it is injecting a shot of fun and enthusiasm behind the effort to keep her music fresh for both the audience and herself.
Where Whitney’s last record Rule 62 made use of retro 60’s sounds, We Still Go To Rodeos works more in the direction of the 80’s and early 90’s punk and Petty-infused rock. She’s aided and abetted in the effort by producer Paul Kolderie whose known for working with folks like Uncle Tupelo and The Pixies, which explains some of the alt-country meets power pop feel that puts a jolt into this record, aided by the appearance of guitar players like Gurf Morlix and Rich Brotherton from her adopted home of Austin.

We Still Go To Rodeos marks Whitney Rose’s first record away from the Canadian-based Six Shooter Records, and on her own label called MCG. But with the spunk and attitude found on the album, think of a project you might hear coming coming from the early roster of Bloodshot Records. When she rears back on “In A Rut,” being stuck never sounded so damn fun. “Better Man” holds a similar appeal with its driving rhythm and immediately infectious appeal. By the time Rose gets to “I’d Rather Be Alone,” the sentiments may still be country, but the sound is all rock.
But that’s just the flavor Whitey chose to make sure she didn’t make the same record twice. At it’s heart, We Still Go To Rodeos is still a country record, and you get a full snoot full of it on the opening track called “Just Circumstance.” Rose wrote every song on the album by herself, and perhaps none better than this track that goes from zero to presenting a character and a scenario that feels sharply real in under four minutes.
Most every song on We Still Go To Rodeos is written as country, including one of the early singles, “Believe Me, Angela” and the steamy “Home With You,” but some end up being rendered with a different coating. “You’d Blame Me For The Rain” finds a Bonnie Raitt mood and melody, but many a country ear will find a connection with never being good enough or fairly appreciated by a significant other.
At the same time, Whitney does run the risk of filing her music in that indefinable “Americana” bin with this record. It’s kind of a gamble, but the hope is that that the overall appeal of really smart and syrupy melodies presented with sensible hooks will draw in a bigger crowd than simple blazing Telecaster and steel guitar, while she makes sure to keep the writing and underlying approach still grounded in the roots.
There is ample heartbreak in We Still Go To Rodeos, it’s just delivered with a bit more rock ‘n roll punch and some wider appeal. Don’t worry, Whitey Rose is still sporting her boots. And so can you while listening to this record. Just don’t forget to have a little fun in them.
1 1/2 Guns Up (7.5/10)
– – – – – – – – – –
Purchase from Whitney Rose
Purchase from Amazon
April 27, 2020 @ 9:43 am
It reminds me of The Jayhawks. I like it a lot.
April 27, 2020 @ 9:45 am
I like the sound of these 2 songs, and I think it’s cool that she wrote the whole album. Nice review.
Just out of curiosity, is this statement based on something she has said as her intention, or is it an assumption:
“But that’s just the flavor Whitey chose to make sure she didn’t make the same record twice”
April 27, 2020 @ 12:50 pm
That’s me paraphrasing, but she said something along those lines in the official press release when the record was announced, so I’d say you could take it to the bank.
April 27, 2020 @ 1:19 pm
Cool, thx.
April 27, 2020 @ 9:51 am
I really enjoyed her earlier stuff. Props to her for making the music she’s wants, but the rock influence isn’t my thing.
April 27, 2020 @ 11:08 am
I’ve given this one a few spins in the last couple days and I think it’s a little more 60’s or 70’s Rock than I have a taste for considering the album is called We Still Go To Rodeo’s. Pleasant enough, but not Country enough. In a Rut is ironic and repetitive, I actually like You’d Blame Me For The Rain and the jazzy little title track but much like Ashley McBryde’s album which I never chimed in on because……….I just don’t find myself going back to it for some reason. The only female artist in my rotation right now besides Kaitlin Butts’ acoustastream (is that a word? It is now!) offerings is Lauren Macitti’s wonderful album which is in heavy rotation.
April 28, 2020 @ 5:55 pm
If you’re looking for more female artists (and I’m not saying you should or shouldn’t), check out Sarah Siskind’s recent album. I think it’s excellent.
April 29, 2020 @ 7:31 am
Well I’ve never had a quota on it but I’ve always hovered around 30-40% female artists just naturally. Obviously throughout the year occasionally there’s more of those releases and Trig usually points em out, but at times I find myself feeling that many females will lean towards other genre’s within their “Country” label like Whitney does or many of the Pop/Country gals do. I know Sarah Shook has one almost done, Sunny Sweeney has a new song out soon and I’ve heard many of her new songs live that I like. Believe me I have the time to check out anything and everything and I will! I’ve got nothing but time….LOL!
May 12, 2020 @ 4:18 pm
When Whitney was in Chicago suburbs Arlington Heights were you there?
May 12, 2020 @ 8:23 pm
No, the place is called Hey Nonny’s in Arlington Hts right up the street from me but I remember I was working that night. I would’ve definitely went, the place is so cool and intimate it holds about 60-75 people. Chris Knight and Emily Scott Robinson both played there. Run by very nice people, they’re struggling to stay afloat right now doing the curbside thing like many independent venue’s.
May 13, 2020 @ 8:00 am
My wife and I were there. I like Hey Nonny’s. Good food and a nice stage. I couldn’t remember the mane. I was able to bring my real camera to the show. I have the pictures.This site doesn’t let me enter photos. Whitney was good. Played many other writers songs. I don’t know why. She writes very well. If you are on Pandora listen to her first cd. It has Doe-Si-Doe on it. Real country honky tonk.
May 3, 2020 @ 3:56 pm
Siskind is wonderful. Thanks for the recommendation, Matt.
April 29, 2020 @ 6:18 am
I really like Caroline Spence’s record too. In a fair world, the song Mint Condition would become a country classic.
April 27, 2020 @ 11:25 am
Album cover is awesome.
April 27, 2020 @ 12:28 pm
Yeah I didn’t want to come off as sexist by saying what I really feel……that the album cover is bad ass smokin’ hot but the music inside doesn’t fit it in my opinion. I was really hoping it would, like say…….Sarah’s Sidelong cover which fits the music perfectly.
April 27, 2020 @ 3:48 pm
When I saw it the first thing I though was Gunfighter Ballads and western music and got a little excited. The songs I’ve heard are not my type of music so I was a little disappointed lol
April 27, 2020 @ 12:38 pm
Whitney was helped by Dale Watson and Ray Benson early on. Seemed at first she was gonna be a traditionalist with a honky tonk leaning. But as time goes on, it appears she’s morphing into something else. Now Tom Petty influenced Rock with an Americana vibe? Following the money I suppose. Well, it happens. Count me not knocked over with excitement.
April 27, 2020 @ 4:54 pm
There’s no money in Americana, or starting your own record label. If she’s following anything, it’s her muse. But I understand if it’s not for everyone, especially more dedicated country fans.
April 30, 2020 @ 11:04 am
lmao yeah tom petty rock is where the money is in 2020. That’s some funny shit
April 30, 2020 @ 12:16 pm
Glad I could provide you with amusement. Trig referred to her sound on this record as Petty infused. I don’t disagree, its got that jingle-jangle rock edge to it. My comment on following the money is more rooted in sarcasm. I will say though that as much as I find fault with Americana, as an organization goes , its got some things going for it. The annual conference in Nashville, the Cayamo annual event, support of NPR and the money from their listeners who support Americana events, Americana charts, radio stations who play it, Ditty TV, Circle TV Austin City Limits, and a lot of other supporters.. If you are a known artist under the Americana category, there are opportunities to make a career within.
Personally, I’m rooting for the more traditional country acts, the honky-tonkers, western swing folks, and the like. My main point in the comment is that Whitney seems to be drawing further away from the country style I initially assumed she wanted to be a part of. I still think she’s super talented and wish her all the best.
But yeah man, its all about Tom Petty in 2020. Guaranteed to make wheelbarrow loads of $$$. (Once again, sarcasm)
April 27, 2020 @ 3:16 pm
Yep, hard not to notice the cover photo. And I’d feel like a bit of an ingrate if I didn’t mention it.
April 27, 2020 @ 11:42 am
Pre-ordered it and CD should be here this afternoon. I have streamed it a few times so far. Not bowled over yet but I want to keep hearing it. That’s a good sign.
April 27, 2020 @ 1:05 pm
Tough one.
It’s a little bit of everything. No real direction.
The instrumentation on “In A Rut” is too loud. The track itself is not bad.
“I’d Rather Be Alone” is my highlight. Not super-country but a good retro-pop-country track.
Not a lot of “Rodeo” on a “Rodeo” album.
In The Pipeline:
Amber Rae – Ride Or Die – EP – 04/30
Gone West – Canyons – Album – 06/11
Jasmine Rae – Lion Side – Album – 07/23
Clint Black – Out Of Sane – Album – 06/19
Oh Jeremiah – Joymonger – Album – 04/30
Jaime Wyatt – Neon Cross – Album – 05/29
Mary McGuinness – Prodigal – Album – 05/07
Jody Direen – Smokin’ Ashes – Album – 07/02
Nobody’s Girl – Nobody’s Girl – Album – 07/09
Will Hoge – Tiny Little Movies – Album – 06/25
Hellbound Glory – Pure Scum – Album – 06/04
Phil Gregory – Good Intentions – Album – 05/01
The Lonely Bastards – Barely Born – EP – 04/30
Megan Collins – You Take Me Home – Album – 07/23
Craig Morgan – God, Family, Country – Album – 05/21
A Different Thread – Some Distant Shore – EP – 05/21
Steve Earle – Ghosts Of West Virginia – Album – 05/22
Paisley Fields – Electric Park Ballroom – Album – 06/04
Courtney Marie Andrews – Old Flowers – Album – 07/16
The McClymonts – Mayhem To Madness – Album – 06/11
Caitlin Cannon – The TrashCannon Album – Album – 05/14
Special Consensus – Chicago Barn Dance – Album – 05/14
Jonathan Parker – Broken Hearts & Broken Bones – Album – 05/01
Various Artists – The Highway Vol.1 (Country Artists You Should Know) – Album – 04/30
&
Roy Drusky – The Singles & Albums Collection 1955-62 – Double Album – 05/07
(Jasmine Rae, Jody Direen & The McClymonts Australia/Australasia)
Canceled or Moved:
Neilly Rich – Love Bender
Gord Bamford – REDNEK
April 27, 2020 @ 3:34 pm
Streamed the album a few times. Liked it enough to put it on my Amazon shopping list; now I’ll see how long I let it smolder there.
Album title did have me expecting more Country content, but maybe the title is signifying that although she’s shifting her style, she’s not totally ditching her roots. I’m beginning to see her more in line with gals such as Nikki Lane or Lindi Ortega – yes they’re retaining a real country component, but they’re stirring in other retro influences. As long as they aren’t obfuscating their vocal gifts I’m willing to give them a listen.
April 27, 2020 @ 4:37 pm
In terms of “vocal gifts,” I think this album does little to showcase that for Whitney. She has a lovely, supple style, capable of punching through at times and delivering the emotion, but I didn’t get much of that here. Her first two albums are the best in that regard. It’s a good album, enjoyable enough, but I would actually say it’s my least favorites of the four LP albums and the South Texas Suite EP.
You are definitely right about the similarities to Nikki Lane and Lindi Ortega.
April 27, 2020 @ 4:53 pm
I think some people’s reactions to this record would be different if Whitney Rose didn’t start out in more of a dedicated honky tonk sound and then started transitioning from there. That’s on the the reasons I mentioned Bloodshot Records. I think if this was a debut album from a performer in the vein of Nikki Lane, people would be lauding it more. I totally understand if you’re a country fan and was hoping for more twang. But I still think this is a country record done more in the 90’s alt-country style of bringing in punk and rock influences.
April 27, 2020 @ 9:18 pm
Yes, I agree it’s still a country record. I like a bit of experimentation. In the mainstream, Eric Church has done it masterfully, albeit imperfectly, which is the risk worth taking. On Rule 62, I liked the occasional 60’s groovy vibe as a nice change of pace and a bit of spice. It was whimsical and fun. This album doesn’t intrigue me in the same way. That’s the risk of experimenting.
I’m a rather big fan of Whitney Rose. Saw her in Charlotte a couple years ago. It may not be my favorite of her LP’s, but it’s still good. I would love to hear some of these songs in a live setting, where she truly shines.
April 27, 2020 @ 6:27 pm
publishers tell songwriters/pitchers they are looking for ‘UP , big-show-energy’ material as more and more acts need to play more and more shows to pay bills . UP songs …rock songs …stand up at these big shows . ballads do not . consequently you hear more of the kinds of things posted here …( think miranda’s ragged -sounding rockier last albums…much of ashley mcbryde’s stuff …almost all of carrie U’s stuff ) ….its generic , not much nuance or virtuso playing …..just show-friendly in terms of energy.
this stuff , to my ear , sounds aimless outside of it being serviceable in the above -mentioned situations .
April 27, 2020 @ 9:12 pm
I like it but TBF my tastes go broad and the bleeding of lines doesn’t bother too much when country gets into Linda Ronstadt/The Eagles territory. Compaired to other country records out now I’d say the review is a fair assessment. COmpared to other album of any genre I think it better than most anything in the top 20 on BIllboard.
April 28, 2020 @ 3:00 am
Whitney Rose is class. If you like music you will like this. Does not matter what kind of label you put on it. It is perfect and she is perfect. God bless Canada. And she released it on time. God Bless Whitney Rose.
April 28, 2020 @ 4:23 am
Still hurtin’ from that Albertan, eh? 😉
All right, this is *completely* speculation on my part, but perhaps with touring off the table, Corb is social distancing by getting busy with ranching or farming, and maybe attempting to support a new release doesn’t make sense for him until the lockdown breaks.
I mean, having to wait eight years for a new release didn’t drive me to boycott Chris Knight.
April 28, 2020 @ 5:58 am
Yep. Did not stop me buying Chris Knight either. Reason was totally different. Hope Corb keeps up his social distancing whilst farming. Leave the cattle and horses alone.
April 28, 2020 @ 7:48 am
Hmm. Would ranching somehow be incompatible with social distancing?
April 28, 2020 @ 8:07 am
And the thing is, we’re just going to have to wait a couple more months for Corb’s new one. It’s been five years since his last album of originals. Yeah, it’s mildly disappointing. But to boycott him over this is just beyond silly.
April 28, 2020 @ 9:02 am
It’s kind of a paradox in a way.
Something is super valuable to someone. The anger of not getting said thing on time is strong enough to forgo having it at all. So the willingness to forgo proves the value was never there to begin with. But if the value was never there to begin with, how can the anger that proves the forgone value even exist? And how could John Connor send someone back in time to prevent his own death?????
April 28, 2020 @ 4:45 pm
I don’t believe her.
April 29, 2020 @ 9:08 am
The production on this album is sparkling. Like, a step above anything she’s produced before.
Can’t wait to hear this on vinyl as the sonics (and the insturment seperation) is amazing, even on crappy spotify lossy codecs.
She’s amazing live, and I highly reccomend checking her out if she is ever your way.
Last show I saw, she was teaching people how to square dance before the show. Such a sweetheart….
April 29, 2020 @ 9:20 am
I have to say I do love that “In A Rut,” but then again I am a sucker for good cowpunk. Although I do wish that guitar solo at the end went for at least 30 seconds more. I was ready to ride it.